Saturday, March 2, 2013

#HB631 #HB616 #SB210 #MOLeg #MOSen #edreform #liberty #statesovereignty

The school district where I teach has always dismissed ineffective teachers.  Our administrators are very thorough and follow through on the procedures required to document unprofessional behavior and ineffective teaching practices.  Additional legislation may be needed to assist some districts and school boards in achieving this task, but I maintain that the procedures have always been in place, even under our current tenure rules.
 
I'm a little concerned about the Value-Added-Model being employed in HB 631 because honestly, my evaluators haven't always been knowledgeable in my subject matter.  It's impossible for administrators/evaluators to know all of the upper level content courses in our schools.  To use VAM in the future, they will be reliant on individual student assessments from current and previous years. 
 
I teach upper-level math to classes of 20-30 students who naturally have widely varying ability levels - yes, even in calculus.  Students at the upper end of the spectrum unfortunately don't progress as far as students at the lower end, over the course of the year, because instructional techniques must remediate for struggling students in order for the entire class to move forward.  I haven't seen a VAM that accommodates for that fact, but it the model exists, we don't have assessments to address this mathematics, and if we did, our state does not have the technological infrastructure to administer the model fairly and accurately across disciplines. 
 
My concern is that the VAM "ideology" precedes the reality of implementation - which is often the case... and the assessments utilized will soon to be associated with mediocre Common Core standards, unless our legislators pass HB616 and SB 210.
 
The Common Core standards movement has gained ground only on ideology from the onset.  When the idea was first discussed four or five years ago, I was like most conservatives in thinking it could be good to have "common" baseline standards for public schools.  Two things changed my mind almost from the onset:  1) they really weren't "baseline" standards because they introduced the 85% cap in the first draft and it remained in the final draft, and 2) there is no virtuous reason that these standards need a copyright, in this day of open source educational materials available from reputable colleges and universities everywhere, unless there was alterior motive.  
 
Those were the things that induced my personal questioning of the CCSS "initiative", but since that time, much substantive research has been conducted by questioning minds through the US.  Although I can't attend the upcoming hearing on SB210, I urge Missouri's legislators to represent their constituents by thoroughly researching the memorandum of agreement that signed away our state's sovereignty in education.
 
MO SB 210 has a hearing scheduled for March 6, 2012 in the Senate Education Committee
 
MO HB 616 has been referred to the Downsizing State Government Committee
[Shouldn't that be Downsizing the FEDERAL Government?] 

 

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Active Links for #MidRiversNewsmagazine LTE on #CCSS

I didn't know this would be published, but since it was...here are the active links.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
When I read the cover title “Changing Curriculum for better or worse” I thought this would be a balanced article, but nothing could be further from the truth. 

 

The Common Core Standards Initiative was NOT “State-Led”

 

The Heritage Foundation and The Pioneer Institute have chronicled the progression of Common Core over the last few years.  It was not state-led as they claim because our locally elected officials were not involved in signing off on the adoptions and public hearings were not held.  Our Governor and State Board of Education signed away our state sovereignty in education and ceded local control of our elected school boards.

 

Please read: 

States Must Reject National Education Standards While There Is Still Time

http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2012/04/states-must-reject-national-education-standards-while-there-is-still-time?query=States+Must+Reject+National+Education+Standards+While+There+Is+Still+Time

 

The Road to a National Curriculum:  The Legal Aspects of the Common Core Standards, Race to the Top, and Conditional Waivers

http://pioneerinstitute.org/download/the-road-to-a-national-curriculum/

 

Common Core Standards are not rigorous or internationally bench-marked

 

Sandra Stotsky in “Common Core Standards’ Devastating Impact on Literary Study and Analytical Thinking” http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2012/12/questionable-quality-of-the-common-core-english-language-arts-standards

 

Common Core’s standards not only present a serious threat to state and local education authority, but also put academic quality at risk. Pushing fatally flawed education standards into America’s schools is not the way to improve education for America’s students.

 

Math Professor Jim Milgram served on the Validation Committee for Common Core and did not sign-off on them. His testimony to the Indiana Senate Education Panel for Hearing on Senate Bill 373 is available here:  http://hoosiersagainstcommoncore.com/math/mathematics-professor-james-milgrams-testimony/

 
Important information from Utahn’s Against Common Core

http://www.utahnsagainstcommoncore.com/truth-in-american-education-vs-a-complete-resource-guide-for-utahs-core-standards/

 

Stotsky served on the official Common Core Validation Committee and was among those who refused to sign off that the Common Core standards were, in fact, adequate.

Commenting on “A Complete Resource Guide On Utah’s Core Standards,”

 

Stotsky states, “lies and unsupported claims” abound in the document.  She also writes:

“the writers didn’t even get the committee I was on right. I was appointed to the Validation Committee, not the Standards Development Committee, and along with the one mathematician on the Validation Committee (and 3 others) eclined to sign off on the final version of Common Core’s standards.

 

The writers keep repeating ad nauseam that Common Core was a state-led effort. Everyone knows most of the effort was financed by the Gates Foundation and that Gates chose the standards writers who had no qualifications for writing K-12 standards in either ELA or math (David Coleman and Jason Zimba).

 

… I frankly can’t spend time on people who can’t document with citations their claims. What country was used for international benchmarking? Where’s the evidence?

The document simply repeats the false claims made by CCSSO from the beginning.”
 
-----------------------------------
This was in the email correspondence, but left out of the printed comment:
 

More Expert Testimony available at What Is Common Core?  Education without Representation

http://whatiscommoncore.wordpress.com/2012/04/09/expert-testimony-about-common-core/

 

Michelle Malking has recently written about Common Core Standards here:

Rotten to the Core (Part 1): Obama’s War on Academic Standards

http://michellemalkin.com/2013/01/23/rotten-to-the-core-obamas-war-on-academic-standards-part-1/

 

Rotten to the Core (Part 2): Readin’, Writin’ and Deconstructionism

http://michellemalkin.com/2013/01/25/rotten-to-the-core-part-2-readin-writin-and-deconstructionism/

 

Rotten to the Core: Reader feedback from the frontlines

http://michellemalkin.com/2013/01/31/rotten-to-the-core-reader-feedback-from-the-frontlines/

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Chamber of Commerce is Wrong about #CommonCore

There is absolutely NO WAY that IN's previous "highly-rated standards were adopted through the same process as was conducted when Indiana adopted the Common Core" because NEVER BEFORE, in US history have state's relinquished control of their educational standards to the Fed DOE.  How could it possibly have been the "same process" - that's clearly FALSE.

State legislature's typically approve the standards developed within their states by appointed state officials. In this case the legislature MUST step-in and stop the agreement signed by those appointed officials because they had NO authority under state constitutions or the US constitution to do so in the first place.

State standards are usually considered minimum competency levels (at least they are in my district).  One has to wonder WHY would Common Core insist on making up 85% of all the standards. Did officials not understand what they were signing?  If so, how could they agree?

Remember - COMMON CORE has a copywrite.  It WILL be 85% of your entire state curriculum (Read the agreement)
 
Chamber of Commerce leaders need to conduct some independent research, rather than relying on soundbites provided by their state's ed establishment. 
 
Legislators - Constituents are depending on YOU to restore local control of education. 
 
Education WITH Representation!!

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Monday, January 21, 2013

Opposition to #CommonCore Is NOT About Avoiding #Accountability

Why I Call Common Core Standards "National" Standards:

Proponents claim they were state-led, but with just a little digging, you can easily find out that they were never vetted publicly and didn't go through any sort of legislative process.  Your state's governor and board of education signed-on to the document which requires local districts to use Common Core Standards because state assessment will be on these standards, with only 15% additional content permissible.  This is one reason I oppose the Common Core Standards "Initiative."

There is nothing wrong with having standards.  It would be great if there were more consistent standards among the states and districts in my opinion, but that does not justify the coercive nature of the Common Core Standards Initiative.  If a set of standards had been developed and vetted publicly, proven to be effective in improving student achievement and cost-effective for districts to adopt, there isn't a district in the country that wouldn't adopt them - with overwhelming support of their patrons.      

Why I Oppose the Common Core Standards Initiative:

In my 21+ career as a high school math teacher, I've read a whoe lot of standards and worked on many curriculum development teams.  My district has always used our state standards as the basis of our work.  Our curriculum teams and PLCs (Professional Learning Communities) improve upon those dramatically, in many areas, to better prepare our students for posts-secondary study and work.  Our intended curriculum is much better than just meeting the level of our state's standards.  Patrons know it and appreciate it, and consistently elect school board members who focus on improving instruction and achievement in our schools.

There are some good math standards in the Common Core.  For example, these are a few that I like:  CCSS.Math.Content.8.G.B.8  CCSS.Math.Content.HSF-IF.B.4  CCSS.Math.Content.HSG-GPE.A.1 

I'm sure that if a set of math standards had been developed and vetted publicly, these would have made that list.  But that isn't how the Common Core Math Standards were developed or adopted.  As it is now, local teachers are faced with the task of "implementing" Common Core as an imperative from their Governor and State Board of Education, while doing so may be in direct conflict with what they believe is best for students.  In order to improve Missouri's math standards, the state should expand on the work of the Curriculum Alignment Iniative which involved K-12 educators, as well as university and college math faculty.  (but that document never saw the light of day)

All About Accountability:

Some legislators seem to think that Common Core Standards will provide the vehicle needed for greater accountability in education.  My district has used common assessments for a long time.  In my opinion, reviewing that assessment data has been a very useful tool for PLC discussions of specific teaching techniques in the content area.  My experience has been that teachers welcome constructive dialogue, even when its critical, if it pertains directly to improving instruction and student achievement. 

On a state-wide basis, we have had district report cards for quite a while now.  If that hasn't improved student achievement, it does not follow that participating in Common Core assessments through the Smarter Balanced Consortium will do so now.  If legislators are simply looking for punitive measures that will make it easier for districts to dismiss ineffective teachers, then I'd suggest there are much less expensive means they could consider - if it were in their purview at all.  I think local districts should develop their own ways to address that problem and that the legislature's role is to free districts to do so.

 

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Monday, December 17, 2012

An Approach to Construction Example 5 #ccssimath #commoncore

Again, image a few things from the onset... Draw PA and construct parallels to it through both B and C.  Construct the perpendicular to these parallels through A.  The following explains how to finish it off...

another_approach.doc Download this file

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Saturday, December 15, 2012

Geometry and #CommonCore #ccsimath

I enjoy reading this blog http://ccssimath.blogspot.com/

Here's an attempt.  You'll have to imagine a couple of things since I don't have the right equipment on this computer: the parallel lines were "constructed" and the curve shown is a compass mark of length AB with center at A.

Construction Example 1 - Construct the perpendicular bisector of the line connecting the two points on the cressent.

Construction Example 2 - Construct the pendicular to segment OB through O, intersecting arc AB at R. Then bisect angle AOR to locate P on arc AB.

Construction Example 3 - Construct the perpendicular bisector of segment XY, this line will intersect line l in the desired point O.

Construction Example 4 - Construct the perpendicular to segment AB at A, then bisect it.  At point B, construct an equilateral triangle having one side on segment AB.  Extend the lines to locate point C in triangle ABC.

Still thinking about Construction Example 5

 

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous

Thursday, December 13, 2012

How Mediocre #Math Programs Gain Market Share in the US [ #edresearch ]

Private Data - The Real Story:
A Huge Problem with
Education Research

R. James Milgram†

Professor of Mathematics Emeritus,
Stanford University, 12/7/2012

Abstract

A very influential paper on improving math outcomes was published in 2008. The authors refused to divulge their data claiming that agreements with the schools and Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) rules prevented it.

  • It turns out that this is not true.
  • The claimed legal foundations do not say what these authors said they do.

 

When we found the identities of the schools by other means, serious problems with the conclusions of the article were quickly revealed.

  • The 2008 paper was far from unique in this respect.
  • There are many papers that have had huge influences on K-12 mathematics curricula, and could not be independently verified because the authors refused to reveal their data.

 

In this article we describe how we were able to find the missing data for the 2008 paper. We discuss the huge difficulties they revealed, and point out the legal constraints that should make it very difficult for authors of such papers to legally withhold their data in the future.

Posted via email from concernedabouteducation's posterous